Mailbag: Is Upton on an upswing?
01/09/2006
What are the Rays' plans for B.J. Upton this year?-- David D., Baltimore, Md.
At this point, there are several options. First, there's the prospect of Upton coming to the Major Leagues at another position, possibly third base. Given his offensive potential and the fact the position is less demanding defensively, Upton would probably fit in nicely at the hot corner. However, from all indications, Upton wants to remain at shortstop, and the Rays seem receptive to letting him exhaust all possibilities at the position. If Julio Lugo is not traded, Upton can continue to work on his defense at Triple-A Durham.
The final option would be to make Upton the Rays' starting shortstop. This seems the least likely possibility, considering his defensive lapses in 2005. After all, the Rays have a young staff, which is more sensitive to defensive lapses.
I think the Devil Rays shouldn't trade away any of their players. What do you think of the team's chances are with their current roster?-- Vinny F., Largo, Fla.
I believe the chances of the 2006 team having a similar look to 2005 are quite possible, which isn't the worst scenario. While trading Aubrey Huff, Danys Baez, Julio Lugo and Joey Gathright would likely strengthen the team for the future, the Rays would be stronger with all of them on board this season. Thus, the Rays, in my opinion, find themselves in a win-win situation. If another team wants to deal fairly with them, they can make trades that will benefit them in the long run; if not, they enter the 2006 campaign with a team that finished last season as one of the more exciting teams in baseball. And it would still be a young team, but with beneficial experience gained during 2005.
Assuming no trades are made prior to the season, what are the chances the Rays will spend money to keep players entering the final year of their contract? If management has no desire to sign these guys for big money, then would it not be better to trade them for something than be left empty-handed at the end of the season? Of course, a trade could also be made during the season.-- Donna M., Odessa, Fla.
Many teams in baseball have valuable personnel with one year remaining on their contracts. If the Rays do not trade the players who have been mentioned as trade bait, those players will remain with the Rays this season and have the opportunity to improve their lots with their performances. If the Rays are pleased with the players' performances, they will have the chance to re-sign them. Let's give the Rays' new management the benefit of the doubt by taking a wait-and-see attitude to see how they treat players who produce on the playing field.
With the crowded situation in Tampa Bay's outfield, do you think it is possible Delmon Young could be traded for some pitching? Or is he too good a prospect to trade away? With Jonny Gomes, Rocco Baldelli, Carl Crawford, Gathright, Huff and Damon Hollins already in the outfield mix, there doesn't seem to be any spot for Young.-- No name or hometown provided
Young is special, so the chances of his being traded are remote. But who knows? The Rays do have a full outfield, so there's always a chance some team could knock off the Rays' socks with an offer they can't refuse. But again, such a deal would have to be of an almost unreal magnitude, given the high esteem in which Young is held by the Rays' front office.
While much has been made about the possibility of the Rays trading Huff, Gathright and/or Lugo for Andy Marte or some other position player, don't you think that swapping a combination of these players for a decent No. 1 or No. 2 starting pitcher would benefit the Rays more? Scott Kazmir could then face another team's No. 3 starter on a regular basis instead of facing off against aces start after start.-- Gary L., Seminole, Fla.
I agree with you that trading for a quality No. 1 or No. 2 starter would be the ideal situation. The problem is, nobody in baseball is trading their top starters. Nearly every team in baseball shares the same problem, which is not having enough proven starting pitching. So the prospect of trading Huff or Gathright for a starter of much consequence is remote.
The best chance the Rays have of getting starting pitching through a trade is by acquiring a youngster with the potential to develop into a proven starter. As for Kazmir, it sounds like new Rays manager Joe Maddon is receptive to letting the young left-hander compete for the No. 1 spot in the rotation. Given that scenario, Rays fans will have to hope Kazmir has the mettle to meet the challenge. From the way he finished the second half of the 2005 season, I think he can pull it off.
I realize that Spring Training is a ways off and a lot can happen between now and then, but how do you see the 25-man Opening Day roster shaping up?-- Doug M., Warsaw, Ind.
If the offseason continues like it has, I believe the 25-man roster will have most of the following names on it:
Outfield: Crawford, Hollins, Gomes, Gathright, Huff and Baldelli.Infielders: Jorge Cantu, Lugo, Sean Burroughs, Nick Green, Huff and Travis Lee.Catchers: Toby Hall and Josh Paul.Starting pitchers: Kazmir, Casey Fossum, Mark Hendrickson, Seth McClung and Doug Waechter.Relievers: Jesus Colome, Tim Corcoran, Travis Harper, Baez, Chad Harville, Chad Orvella and Lance Carter.
Source: http://tampabay.devilrays.mlb.com/